Baked Sweet Plantains


Yes, we had another birthday this past weekend.  James turned 22 and how that happened I can’t even begin to comprehend.  Suffice it to say he will always be my “Wainbow” from Mrs. “Shop’s” Pre-K class.  That’s supposed to be Rainbow and Mrs. Sharp  but when you’re 5 years old, well, some letters are just harder to pronounce than others.  As in so many homes the birthday person gets to pick the menu for their family party and James went Latino.  Roast pork Puerto Rican style, black beans and rice, big ass salad, and maduros, sweet, yellow plantains roasted to melting perfection.  And let’s don’t forget dessert.  We decided upon homemade Key Lime Pie AND, to gild the lily, Guava and Cream Cheese Flan.  Scary but true.  I had a lot of preparation and cooking ahead of me.  First things first I made a large slit actually separating the fat from the meat and then slathered the fat with a paste I had made out of garlic, oregano and salt.  Fat back in place, the pork was ready to hang out in the refrigerator and soak up the heady flavors until roasting time.  Next came the desserts.  Key Lime Pie.  I use the recipe from Joe’s Stone Crabs.  Tart and not too sweet, the pie is a no-fail every time.  And I double it as I like a deep dish Key Lime Pie.  As the pie cooled after it’s brief sojourn in the oven I moved on to the flan.  The preparation of flan always makes me a little skittish because the caramel sauce is just so, SO integral to the silkiness of the custard and sometimes it doesn’t come out quite right.  Mama’s flan was legendary.  It was the only dish she could make that was out of this world.  And hers always yielded plenty of syrup.  Thankfully, this one went without a hitch.  I tasted the custard, pink with guava and almost swooned.  I gave James a taste and he just rolled his eyes.  It’s crazy good!  I had placed the pork in a pyrex dish, tightly bundled in plastic wrap.  With a metal cooling rack carefully positioned on top of the pork shoulder I gently slid the foil wrapped flan on top.  Then I placed another cooling rack on top of the flan and the pie was ready to go in.  The cooling racks steady the dessert pans and I chose to put the pie on top of the flan so as not to compromise the crust or leave any unattractive marks on the pie filling.  All this was done on Friday to be served to the family on Sunday.  Early Sunday morning I took the pork out of the refrigerator to come to room temperature before roasting.  I made the black beans and rice and prepared the plantains just to the point of baking.  I bought them on Friday and they were kind of ripe but not ripe enough.  Not by a long shot.  I put the bag holding 12 plantains on the window sill to hasten the process.  I was a little worried.  But for naught!  The peels came right off and my knife slid right though them.  Their natural sweetness enhanced by my addition of rum and light brown sugar I set them aside wrapped in tin foil and ready for the oven.


I still needed to set up our hors d’oeuvre.  On a back counter in the kitchen I set out a small bowl of organic, golden grape tomatoes.  On a two-foot long olive wood board I placed several different cheeses flanked by two more pretty bowls holding white, seedless grapes.  I did put out one box of water crackers but that was it.  And it was perfect!  The hit of the birthday dinner?  Hands down, the plantains.  The lowly, starchy fruit loved by jibaros everywhere slid into home plate with a buttered rum homer!  They’re addictive, sweet and satisfying so be careful.  It’s a slippery slope with them.  But once a year is fine. Buen provecho!



I always allow one plantain per person and then throw in a few extra.  The plantains are so good that guests usually help themselves to a little bit more, maybe just one more bite…they’re good looking, sexy and can be served as a side, as I did, or as dessert over vanilla ice cream.  I would be UN.DONE. if I had a bowl of that in front of me!  They can be prepared a few hours in advance of roasting and the preparation is about as simple as it gets.  Sweet plantains are quite rich so pace yourselves!

Baked Sweet Plantains - Platanos Maduros

  • Servings: 6
  • Difficulty: easy
  • Print

  • 1/2 stick of cold butter
  • 6 or 7 extremely ripe plantains, if the skin isn’t black it should be at least seriously mottled with black spots.  This indicates ripeness, hence, sweetness.
  • decent rum, golden or dark.  My preference is a golden Puerto Rican rum called Ron del Barrilito.  It’s what my father used to drink a thousand years ago.
  • one handful of light or dark brown sugar
  1. Preheat oven to 350°.
  2. Cut the cold butter into equally thin pieces and line the bottom of a 9X13 pan with them.  There can be space in between the pieces as the butter will melt and cover the entire bottom of the pan.
  3. Cut the ends off the plantains and then make a very shallow cut in the skin from the top of the fruit to the bottom.
  4. Peel off the skin and discard.
  5. Cut the plantains in half and then cut each half lengthwise to make two equal, stumpy pieces.
  6. Cover the butter in the baking dish laying the plantain pieces snugly side by side.  It’s fine to go up the sides of the dish as the plantains shrink a bit upon baking so the end result is they’ll all fit nicely and brown in the butter.
  7.  Sprinkle with rum.  I sprinkle straight from the bottle putting my thumb lightly over the mouth of the bottle.  The alcohol burns off in baking so don’t worry!
  8.  Scatter a healthy handful of brown sugar evenly over the plantains.
  9. Cover dish tightly with tin foil and bake for 25 minutes.
  10. Remove and discard tin foil and turn all the plantains over.
  11. Spoon some of the rum butter sauce over the maduros and continue baking, uncovered, for another 15 minutes.  And that’s it!!  Enjoy!


  1. Dawn

    I was so happy to see this post. I had been thinking of asking you how to make plantains. While I didn’t grow up with them, they have become a favorite of ours when dining out, and I didn’t have any idea how to prepare them. Can’t wait to try this and Have to go shopping today! Thanks!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.